Datasets:
Reddit Car Posts and Comments
Every post and comment from 22 car-related subreddits, January 2025 through September 2026 (posts through October 2026): 710,799 posts and 11,046,345 comments, about 1.5 GB of Parquet.
The subreddits cover general car talk and buying advice, car brands, electric vehicles, in-car software (CarPlay, Android Auto), self-driving, and ride-hailing drivers:
| Group | Subreddits |
|---|---|
| General | r/cars, r/whatcarshouldIbuy, r/Autos |
| Brands | r/BMW, r/mercedes_benz, r/Audi, r/Volkswagen, r/Toyota, r/Honda, r/Hyundai, r/kia, r/Ford, r/Volvo |
| EV | r/electricvehicles, r/teslamotors, r/RealTesla, r/Ioniq5, r/MachE |
| Software & connectivity | r/CarPlay, r/AndroidAuto, r/SelfDrivingCars |
| Drivers | r/uberdrivers |
Usage
from datasets import load_dataset
posts = load_dataset("aliarda/reddit-car-post-and-comments", "posts", split="train")
comments = load_dataset("aliarda/reddit-car-post-and-comments", "comments", split="train")
Files are laid out as <posts|comments>/<subreddit>/<YYYY-MM>.parquet, so one subreddit or month can be
loaded on its own:
ev = load_dataset("aliarda/reddit-car-post-and-comments", data_files="comments/electricvehicles/*.parquet", split="train")
import pandas as pd
df = pd.read_parquet("hf://datasets/aliarda/reddit-car-post-and-comments/posts/CarPlay/2026-01.parquet")
The dataset is gated: request access on this page and it is approved manually.
Columns
All timestamps are Unix seconds, UTC.
posts
| Column | Type | Description |
|---|---|---|
id |
string | Post id (without the t3_ prefix) |
subreddit |
string | Subreddit name |
author |
string | Username; [deleted] if the account was deleted |
created_utc |
int64 | When the post was made |
title |
string | Title |
selftext |
string | Body of a text post; empty for link posts; [removed] / [deleted] if taken down |
url |
string | Link target; for image/video posts the i.redd.it / v.redd.it file, for galleries reddit.com/gallery/<id> |
domain |
string | Domain of url (self.<subreddit> for text posts) |
permalink |
string | Path of the post on reddit.com |
link_flair_text |
string | Post flair |
author_flair_text |
string | Author's flair in that subreddit |
score |
int64 | Score when retrieved (see retrieved_on) |
upvote_ratio |
float64 | Share of upvotes when retrieved |
num_comments |
int64 | Comment count when retrieved |
num_crossposts |
int64 | Times crossposted |
crosspost_parent |
string | Full id (t3_…) of the original post if this is a crosspost |
post_hint |
string | Reddit's content hint: image, link, hosted:video, rich:video, self |
is_self |
bool | Text post |
is_video |
bool | Reddit-hosted video |
over_18 |
bool | Marked NSFW |
spoiler |
bool | Marked spoiler |
stickied |
bool | Pinned by moderators |
locked |
bool | Comments locked |
distinguished |
string | moderator / admin if posted in an official capacity |
removed_by_category |
string | Why it was removed (moderator, deleted, reddit, automod_filtered, …); empty if not removed |
retrieved_on |
int64 | When Arctic Shift collected the post |
comments
| Column | Type | Description |
|---|---|---|
id |
string | Comment id (without the t1_ prefix) |
subreddit |
string | Subreddit name |
author |
string | Username; [deleted] if the account was deleted |
created_utc |
int64 | When the comment was made |
body |
string | Comment text (Markdown); [removed] / [deleted] if taken down |
link_id |
string | Post the comment belongs to (t3_<post id>), joins to posts.id |
parent_id |
string | Parent: the post (t3_…) for top-level comments, otherwise a comment (t1_…) |
permalink |
string | Path of the comment on reddit.com |
author_flair_text |
string | Author's flair in that subreddit |
score |
int64 | Score when retrieved |
controversiality |
int64 | 1 if Reddit flagged the comment as controversial |
is_submitter |
bool | Written by the post's author |
stickied |
bool | Pinned by moderators |
distinguished |
string | moderator / admin if posted in an official capacity |
retrieved_on |
int64 | When Arctic Shift collected the comment |
To rebuild threads, join comments.link_id (minus t3_) to posts.id, and follow parent_id upwards.
Size
By subreddit
| Subreddit | Posts | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| r/whatcarshouldIbuy | 115,442 | 1,700,293 |
| r/electricvehicles | 30,463 | 1,367,995 |
| r/BMW | 84,990 | 1,138,321 |
| r/uberdrivers | 61,240 | 1,068,818 |
| r/cars | 36,284 | 962,074 |
| r/Audi | 64,496 | 803,205 |
| r/mercedes_benz | 44,948 | 552,173 |
| r/RealTesla | 8,078 | 371,880 |
| r/Ioniq5 | 18,534 | 356,691 |
| r/Toyota | 27,460 | 347,823 |
| r/Volvo | 33,851 | 343,519 |
| r/Honda | 36,911 | 327,777 |
| r/Hyundai | 26,116 | 269,039 |
| r/MachE | 12,995 | 259,441 |
| r/Volkswagen | 32,081 | 255,228 |
| r/SelfDrivingCars | 5,444 | 219,442 |
| r/kia | 18,548 | 189,277 |
| r/Ford | 18,104 | 170,841 |
| r/teslamotors | 10,921 | 138,802 |
| r/Autos | 6,684 | 68,973 |
| r/AndroidAuto | 8,179 | 67,383 |
| r/CarPlay | 9,030 | 67,350 |
| Total | 710,799 | 11,046,345 |
By month
| Month | Posts | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| 2025-01 | 43,360 | 653,416 |
| 2025-02 | 37,571 | 575,850 |
| 2025-03 | 41,072 | 669,255 |
| 2025-04 | 37,102 | 574,779 |
| 2025-05 | 36,903 | 562,632 |
| 2025-06 | 34,702 | 549,052 |
| 2025-07 | 37,316 | 574,245 |
| 2025-08 | 36,549 | 520,064 |
| 2025-09 | 33,165 | 497,997 |
| 2025-10 | 32,656 | 499,807 |
| 2025-11 | 31,209 | 466,152 |
| 2025-12 | 30,378 | 515,444 |
| 2026-01 | 32,088 | 522,128 |
| 2026-02 | 29,209 | 463,481 |
| 2026-03 | 31,994 | 504,604 |
| 2026-04 | 31,062 | 495,299 |
| 2026-05 | 29,875 | 498,746 |
| 2026-06 | 26,116 | 467,783 |
| 2026-07 | 26,949 | 468,124 |
| 2026-08 | 25,579 | 475,396 |
| 2026-09 | 22,999 | 461,145 |
| 2026-10 | 22,945 | 30,946 (r/cars only, see below) |
Cockpit classifier scores
scores/student_scores.parquet gives every eligible post and comment a score: the probability that it
expresses a problem, need, preference or question about the car cockpit (screens, infotainment, physical
controls, seats, climate, CarPlay/Android Auto, voice assistants, ADAS alerts, visibility, cabin noise and
roominess). The scores come from the student classifier
aliarda/reddit-car-cockpit-student, trained on
LLM-teacher labels from aliarda/reddit-car-sample-50k.
from datasets import load_dataset
scores = load_dataset("aliarda/reddit-car-post-and-comments", "scores", split="train")
| Column | Type | Description |
|---|---|---|
uid |
string | t3_<id> for a post, t1_<id> for a comment; joins to posts.id / comments.id after the prefix |
kind |
string | post or comment |
subreddit |
string | Subreddit name |
created_utc |
int | When the item was made (Unix seconds, UTC) |
p_yes |
float | The classifier's probability that the item is about the cockpit |
Which items are scored: 10,418,742 of the 11,757,144 items. Left out, as in the classifier's training data:
anything by AutoModerator, [deleted] / [removed] texts, and texts shorter than 20 characters (for posts,
title + selftext). Each item was scored with its context: the post title and, for replies, the parent comment.
Which threshold to use:
- 0.001 to find candidates: keeps about 90% of what the teacher calls cockpit, but about half of the flagged items are not cockpit, so check them with a stronger model.
- 0.08 if the score is used on its own: about 73% precision and 76% recall against the teacher.
The scores are not calibrated probabilities; treat them as a ranking and use the thresholds above.
| Subreddit | Scored | Flagged @ 0.001 | Flagged @ 0.08 |
|---|---|---|---|
| r/AndroidAuto | 57,502 | 49,447 (86.0%) | 36,197 (62.9%) |
| r/CarPlay | 69,332 | 56,257 (81.1%) | 41,667 (60.1%) |
| r/MachE | 247,141 | 86,622 (35.0%) | 47,021 (19.0%) |
| r/Ioniq5 | 350,336 | 114,302 (32.6%) | 62,387 (17.8%) |
| r/teslamotors | 114,775 | 34,149 (29.8%) | 19,585 (17.1%) |
| r/Volvo | 327,394 | 98,523 (30.1%) | 53,396 (16.3%) |
| r/Audi | 753,190 | 184,858 (24.5%) | 102,911 (13.7%) |
| r/mercedes_benz | 514,603 | 123,345 (24.0%) | 62,461 (12.1%) |
| r/Hyundai | 270,292 | 56,592 (20.9%) | 29,750 (11.0%) |
| r/kia | 189,634 | 38,100 (20.1%) | 19,972 (10.5%) |
| r/cars | 877,874 | 149,020 (17.0%) | 92,011 (10.5%) |
| r/whatcarshouldIbuy | 1,649,973 | 257,244 (15.6%) | 165,150 (10.0%) |
| r/Volkswagen | 254,812 | 59,902 (23.5%) | 25,191 (9.9%) |
| r/BMW | 1,040,513 | 216,893 (20.8%) | 102,334 (9.8%) |
| r/Toyota | 332,587 | 55,957 (16.8%) | 29,800 (9.0%) |
| r/SelfDrivingCars | 210,646 | 42,980 (20.4%) | 18,569 (8.8%) |
| r/electricvehicles | 1,322,639 | 174,546 (13.2%) | 111,718 (8.4%) |
| r/Autos | 64,025 | 10,361 (16.2%) | 4,908 (7.7%) |
| r/Ford | 168,877 | 27,301 (16.2%) | 12,874 (7.6%) |
| r/RealTesla | 313,358 | 34,357 (11.0%) | 17,575 (5.6%) |
| r/Honda | 311,057 | 43,898 (14.1%) | 17,293 (5.6%) |
| r/uberdrivers | 978,182 | 56,901 (5.8%) | 20,039 (2.0%) |
| Total | 10,418,742 | 1,971,555 (18.9%) | 1,092,809 (10.5%) |
Cockpit problems, needs and preferences (LLM extraction)
The extraction/ folder holds what a large language model found in a stratified sample of 200,000 of the
1,971,555 items the classifier flags at p_yes >= 0.001: whether each item really is about the cockpit and, if
so, which cockpit element it is about, the person's stance, and a verbatim quote.
Headline numbers (weighted to the flagged pool):
- 50.5% of flagged items are confirmed as cockpit, about 995,000 posts and comments. The classifier lets through about 90% of cockpit items at this threshold, so the true total is somewhat higher.
- 1.32 million cockpit points (an item can make up to 3), 51% of them problems.
- 99.1% of the extracted quotes appear verbatim in the text.
| Element | Share of mentions | Problem | Need | Preference | Praise | Question |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
infotainment_screen |
15.4% | 60% | 5% | 14% | 15% | 7% |
controls |
11.9% | 48% | 5% | 25% | 16% | 6% |
interior_design_materials |
11.9% | 48% | 2% | 21% | 26% | 3% |
phone_integration |
9.4% | 55% | 10% | 13% | 11% | 11% |
space_storage |
8.6% | 38% | 13% | 14% | 30% | 5% |
seats_ergonomics |
6.7% | 33% | 8% | 20% | 34% | 5% |
automated_driving |
6.7% | 57% | 5% | 10% | 21% | 6% |
connected_services |
6.0% | 66% | 5% | 9% | 10% | 10% |
adas_alerts |
5.1% | 60% | 7% | 9% | 16% | 8% |
visibility_cameras |
3.7% | 49% | 11% | 14% | 18% | 7% |
climate_controls |
3.6% | 45% | 10% | 18% | 21% | 6% |
instrument_cluster_hud |
3.5% | 50% | 6% | 17% | 14% | 13% |
audio |
3.1% | 41% | 6% | 22% | 24% | 7% |
cabin_noise |
2.7% | 47% | 4% | 10% | 35% | 4% |
voice_assistant |
1.1% | 65% | 4% | 10% | 15% | 5% |
other |
0.8% | 49% | 9% | 21% | 12% | 10% |
Shares are of weighted mentions; the stance columns split each element's mentions.
Tables
from datasets import load_dataset
items = load_dataset("aliarda/reddit-car-post-and-comments", "extraction_items", split="train")
mentions = load_dataset("aliarda/reddit-car-post-and-comments", "extraction_mentions", split="train")
extraction/extract_items.parquet, one row per sampled item (200,000):
| Column | Description |
|---|---|
uid, kind, subreddit, created_utc |
the item (t3_/t1_ + id) |
p_yes |
the classifier's score |
weight |
how many flagged items this sampled item stands for (see Sampling) |
label |
YES (about the cockpit) or NO; null for 232 items the model gave no valid answer for |
car_make, car_model |
the car the text is about, when the text makes it clear |
n_mentions |
number of cockpit points extracted |
error, finish_reason, n_output_tokens |
answer diagnostics |
reasoning |
the model's thinking, truncated to 3,000 characters |
extraction/extract_mentions.parquet, one row per cockpit point of a YES item (133,583):
| Column | Description |
|---|---|
uid, kind, subreddit, created_utc, weight, car_make, car_model |
copied from the item |
position |
0 for the item's main point, then 1, 2 |
element |
one of the 16 elements below |
stance |
problem, need, preference, praise or question |
intensity |
1 mild, 2 clear, 3 strong (anger, a dealbreaker, a safety concern) |
issue |
what the point is about, at most 12 generic words (e.g. "touchscreen lag") |
quote |
the shortest span of the text that shows it |
quote_found |
whether the quote appears verbatim in the text (whitespace and case ignored) |
Elements: infotainment_screen (center screen and its software), instrument_cluster_hud, controls
(buttons, knobs, touch/haptic buttons, steering-wheel controls, stalks, gear selector, pedals), climate_controls,
phone_integration (CarPlay, Android Auto, Bluetooth, charging, USB), voice_assistant, connected_services
(apps, digital key, OTA updates, subscriptions), audio, seats_ergonomics, space_storage (room, child seats,
cabin storage, cupholders), interior_design_materials, visibility_cameras, adas_alerts (warnings, chimes,
lane keeping, adaptive cruise, driver monitoring), automated_driving, cabin_noise, other.
Using the weights
Every number meant to describe the flagged pool should be weighted: sum weight instead of counting rows.
import duckdb
duckdb.sql("CREATE SECRET (TYPE huggingface, PROVIDER credential_chain)") # uses your `hf auth login` (gated dataset)
duckdb.sql("""
SELECT element, sum(weight) AS mentions, sum(weight) FILTER (WHERE stance = 'problem') / sum(weight) AS problem_share
FROM 'hf://datasets/aliarda/reddit-car-post-and-comments/extraction/extract_mentions.parquet'
GROUP BY element ORDER BY mentions DESC
""").show()
Sampling
From the 1,971,555 items with p_yes >= 0.001, each subreddit got its share of the 200,000, but at least 3,000
items (this lifted r/Ford and r/Autos), drawn at random within the subreddit with a fixed seed. weight = the
subreddit's flagged items / its sampled items (3.45 for r/Autos, 9.10 for r/Ford, 9.97 for all others).
How it was made
- Model:
google/gemma-4-26B-A4B-itwith thinking, vLLM 0.32.0 on 8 × NVIDIA H200 (TRUBA, TÜBİTAK ULAKBİM), temperature 1.0, top_p 0.95, top_k 64, up to 7,168 output tokens, about 1 h 45 min. - Prompt: the same YES/NO rules used to label the classifier's training data
(aliarda/reddit-car-sample-50k), followed by the
JSON answer format with the element list. Both are in
scripts/extract_teacher.py. - Input per item: post title, parent comment for replies, and the text, as for the classifier.
- Choice of model: on 500 sample items, Gemma 4 26B-A4B, Gemma 4 31B and Qwen3.8-27B agreed with each other on YES/NO 86–88% of the time (Cohen's kappa 0.73–0.77) and picked the same main element 86–90% of the time when both said YES. Gemma 26B agreed with the majority of the three on 93.6% of items and was the fastest.
- Scripts:
draw_sample.py(sample and weights),extract_teacher.py(prompt, parsing, quote check),postprocess_extract.py(these tables),extract.slurm.
Limitations
- One model, no human check yet. Labels and extractions come from a single LLM; borderline items (passing mentions, replies that depend on the parent comment) are where it is least reliable.
- Items the classifier scored below 0.001 are not covered. They hold the roughly 10% of cockpit items the classifier misses; totals here are for the flagged pool.
- Elements and issues are the model's wording.
issueis free text; similar issues are worded differently and need grouping before counting by theme.
How it was collected
All data comes from Arctic Shift, an archive of public Reddit data.
- 2025-01 to 2026-09 comes from Arctic Shift's monthly dumps (one file of every Reddit post and one of every comment per month, about 1.3 TB in total). Each dump was streamed, filtered down to these 22 subreddits, and written to Parquet without being stored in full.
- 2026-10 comes from the Arctic Shift API, because that month's dump was not out yet when this was built.
Checks
Row counts were compared with Arctic Shift's own per-subreddit monthly counts:
- Posts, 2025-01: identical for every subreddit.
- Comments, 2025-01: identical for 20 of 21 subreddits; r/cars has 9 fewer (58,260 vs 58,269).
- Comments, 2026-07: 77 fewer out of about 422,000 (0.02%), spread over a few subreddits.
The small shortfalls are most likely items Arctic Shift added to its database after the dump was built. Arctic Shift publishes no counts for r/uberdrivers, so it could not be checked.
Limitations
- October 2026 comments are incomplete: only r/cars is included so far. October posts are complete. The month will be filled in from the October dump.
- Scores are snapshots.
score,upvote_ratioandnum_commentsare the values when Arctic Shift collected the item (retrieved_on), which can be soon after it was posted, so they may be lower than the final values. - Removed and deleted content stays in the dataset as
[removed]/[deleted]text or authors, as it was when collected. - Only some fields are kept. Reddit items have over 100 fields; the ones above cover text, authorship,
scores, thread structure and moderation. Media metadata is not included: image galleries are only linked
through
url, not as individual image links.
License and use
The content belongs to the Reddit users who wrote it and is subject to Reddit's terms. This dataset is shared for research only, and access is gated. Usernames are kept as they appear on Reddit; please don't use the data to identify or target individuals.
- Downloads last month
- 8,340